The Common Threads in Transformed Churches

The Common Threads in Transformed Churches

Researcher points to power of appreciation, the invitation and storytelling

Churches that have introduced Appreciative Inquiry (AI) are seeing what researcher Cameron Eccleston calls “transformative” results, but what’s most at play in these outcomes?

In a recent Axiom News interview, Eccleston, who is completing graduate research on the use of AI in North American churches, found three common threads in the churches that saw results.

First, he found that appreciating what’s working was important in some cases.

This was particularly true in churches that had gone through some recent challenge.

In two scenarios, churches had suffered trauma and were on the brink of closing their doors.

“Speaking in terms of what was good about the church and not what was wrong was essential in breathing life back into those churches,” says Eccleston.

“In both cases the churches now appear to be thriving under new leadership.”

In addition to appreciating, Eccleston found it was essential that the AI process be introduced by church leaders in a spirit of true openness and belief that the whole system has solutions to offer and can help co-create a new future.

“As soon as AI is imposed on a congregation rather than invited in, I believe it is destined to fail,” says Eccleston.

He notes the successful processes he studied were largely laity driven and had a very supportive leadership team. They were prepared to trust the process and accept any outcomes that emerged.

In addition to the appreciative and invitational approach, most essential to the success of AI is the ability to listen and tell stories, says Eccleston.

“Without a doubt, the common thread that links those churches that saw results and transformation came as a result of the storytelling.”

As people listened and shared, they realized, for the first time in many cases, ““that they weren’t alone, that others felt the way they did.”

In one of the cases AI didn’t have the same transformational impact. Eccleston says he believes this was because the AI interviews were largely substituted for the process of online surveys that were complex and neglected the importance of storytelling in forging a common narrative.

He adds his belief in storytelling as an integral success factor was deepened after seeing that even in churches where the discover and dream phases of the AI model were done well but the latter two, design and destiny, somewhat neglected, these churches still saw transformation and increased health. It was the power of the storytelling that happened in the first two phases that generated these outcomes, Eccleston says.

For a related story, click here.

If you have a story to share, or feedback on this article, please contact Michelle at 800-294-0051, ext. 27, or e-mail michelle(at)

Writer Bio

Michelle Strutzenberger's picture
Michelle Strutzenberger

Michelle Strutzenberger has been a Generative Journalist and curator with Axiom News for more than 15 years.

She's most grateful for the incredible people she gets to work with every day at Axiom News, as well as the many other amazing folks she's encountered through this work.

"I have always seen the opportunity to do this work as a gift," she says.

Michelle's writing has also been published by a wide variety of other organizations and publications, including the following:
- Abundant Community, an initiative of authors John McKnight and Peter Block to awaken the power of families and neighbourhoods
- PLAN Institute, a network dedicated to enabling families to create a good life for people with disabilities
-.New Scoop YYC, Calgary's news co-op practicing Generative Journalism
- The Canadian Community Economic Development Network
- Nieuwmakers, a Belgian news agency
- Restore Commons, an initiative of Peter Block and friends
- Academy for Systemic Change

Contact Michelle: 705-741-4421 ext. 27 or michelle(at)

Reprint This Story

Axiom News content is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Unported License. Stories may be reprinted in their entirety with permission and when appropriately credited.

Please contact Axiom News at
1-800-294-0051 for more information.